reading
Sunday, 28 June 2015 - 2:05pm
This week, I have been mostly reading:
- “The Art of the Gouge”: NYU as a Model for Predatory Higher Education - Yves Smith, Naked Capitalism: "Under Chairman of the Board Martin Lipton and President John Sexton, New York University has been to operate as a real estate development/management business with a predatory higher-education side venture."
- Tent cities: Seattle’s unique approach to homelessness - Sara Bernard at Grist: "Nickelsville is one of several roving tent cities in Seattle. Christened in a deliberate slam against Seattle’s former mayor, Greg Nickels, whose administration regularly cleared homeless encampments, it has relocated about 20 times since its creation in 2008."
- How to Fix Patents: Economic Liberty Requires Patent Reform - Derek Satya Khanna proffers an intellectually honest conservative/libertarian view for Lincoln Labs: "Only in a place that can honestly argue that pizza is a vegetable can someone with a straight face pretend that patents to “slide to unlock” and the idea of “podcasting” are property."
- Almost half of all people released from the prison system become homeless - by whoever does the UniMelb press releases: "Contributing report author Dr Julie Moschion from the University of Melbourne said that the study found that the longer the time spent in prison the longer the individual was likely to be homeless."
- Stop Calling the TPP A Trade Agreement – It Isn’t - Dave johnson at Common Dreams: "“Trade” is a propaganda word. It short-circuits thinking. People hear “trade” and the brain stops working. People think, “Of course, trade is good.” And that ends the discussion."
- UNSW grads the top choice for 30 most in-demand employers - Leilah Schubert of, erm, the UNSW Media Office: Sounds legit.
- Everything You Ever Wanted To Know About Why We Torture Asylum Seekers, But Were Too Afraid To Ask - Lissa Johnson, New Matilda: "Julian Burnside said, “In my naivety, I thought that if the rest of Australia knew the things that I had learned, the Government’s refugee policy would not long survive.” Yet here we are, 13 years later."
- Inside NSA, Officials Privately Criticize “Collect It All” Surveillance - Peter Maas at The Intercept: "An amusing parable circulated at the NSA a few years ago. Two people go to a farm and purchase a truckload of melons for a dollar each. They then sell the melons along a busy road for the same price, a dollar. As they drive back to the farm for another load, they realize they aren’t making a profit, so one of them suggests, “Do you think we need a bigger truck?”"
- Rand Paul Got One (Huge) Thing Right - Bill Boyarsky at Truthdig: "The fact that Paul brought up the connection between the NSA’s domestic spying and local law enforcement is tremendously important. In doing so, he highlighted the fact that federal drug officers and their local allies have secret access to the NSA’s powerful information-gathering tools. Thus, they can skate around Supreme Court decisions requiring prosecutors to show evidence to defense lawyers."
- Al Qaeda Syria Boss Says That His “So-Called Khorasan Group Doesn’t Exist” - Murtasa Hussain, The Intercept: "While the “Khorasan Group” designation itself was partly a fiction created by the U.S. government, simply a nickname created for a group of people within Syria whom it wanted to bomb, it was reported at the time in hyperbolic media reports as not only a real, discrete organization, but also a more dangerous threat to Americans than the Islamic State." The world is one big Gulf of Tonkin.
- TISA: Yet Another Leaked Treaty You've Never Heard Of Makes Secret Rules for the Internet - Jeremy Malcom at the EFF: Yikes! "The agreement would also prohibit countries from enacting free and open source software mandates. Although “software used for critical infrastructure” is already carved out from this prohibition (and so is software that is not “mass market software”, whatever that means), there are other circumstances in which a country might legitimately require suppliers to disclose their source code."
- How Mainstream is Bernie Sanders? - Juan Cole: "Climate change denialists are kooks, and if we had an honest media, it would call them kooks. Instead, Bernie Sanders, whose positions are shared by strong majorities of Americans, is being depicted as the one who is out of step."
- Political donations from Universities should be prohibited - Press release from the Australian Greens: "'It is a sad reflection on the contemporary higher education sector, as well as the state of politics generally, that universities feel as though making political donations is the best way to influence the political debate,' said Senator Rhiannon."
- Niall Ferguson’s Wishful Thinking - Robert Skidelsky at Project Syndicate: While it's not news that ridiculous fop Ferguson continues to be wrong in every important respect, this graph is particularly telling:
I wish I could locate again the corresponding graph for employment growth since the start of the recession, which shows employment roughly following same the trendline during the recovery, despite productivity flatlining. This is what you'd expect from a punitive social security system that forces people to take the first job going, rather than the one for which they are best suited. - Poisoning the Well, or How Economic Theory Damages Moral Imagination - Julie A. Nelson: "[…] defining economics around models of individual rational choice is only one option. A far better one, with a longer history, is to think of economics as being about how societies organize themselves to support human life and its flourishing—or about how they fail to do so. Such a 'provisioning' definition of economics encompasses both markets and families, both money and care. The neurological and psychological research reveals that when we say that economics is about 'rational choice in the face of scarcity,' we stack the deck in favor of individualism and selfishness. Contrast this to saying that economics is about 'who gets to eat and who does not.' The latter packs a visceral punch and directs us towards investigating social relations."
- The age of open financial imperialism - Branko Milanovic: "[…] a combination of good statistics with lack of knowledge of history, produces useless results. It is as if one were to study today’s racial wage gap in the US without knowing that there ever was slavery."
- Beyond the Middle East: The Rohingya Genocide - Ramzy Baroud at Uncommon Thought Journal: "It is not easy to sell Burma as a democracy while its people are hunted down like animals, forced into deplorable camps, trapped between the army and the sea where thousands have no other escape but “leaky boats” and the Andaman Sea. Abbott might want to do some research before blaming the Rohingyas for their own misery."
- The Finnish Diesease - Paul Krugman, NYT: "Why can’t Finland recover this time? Debt is not a problem; borrowing costs are very low. But it’s all about the euro straitjacket. In 1990 the country could and did devalue, achieving a rapid gain in competitiveness. This time not, so that there is no quick way to adjust to adverse shocks"
- The Hypocrisy of the Internet Journalist: I’m selling you out as hard as I can, and I’m sorry - Quinn Norton at Medium: "For years, as a regular writer at Wired, I watched this system grow up with unease. I watched more companies put tracking cookies and scripts in every article I wrote. As my career went on, that list kept getting longer. Unlike most of the people I worked with at Wired, I understood the implications of what we were doing."
- What kind of government service puts public on hold for 811 years? - Kristin Natalier in the Conversation: In the punitive social security—sorry, I mean "human services" (because there is no society and certainly no security)—system, wasting time is a feature, not a bug.
- Why it would be good for the IMF if Greece stopped repaying the IMF loans - Bodo Ellmers, guest blogging at TripleCrisis: "The most effective way to prevent irresponsible lending is to make it clear to lenders that they won’t see their money back if they lend irresponsibly. This is why Greece should default on the IMF loans and force the IMF to write them off. This would substantially strengthen the more prudent voices in the IMF decision-making processes."
- The Student Loan Crisis and the Debtfare State - Susanne Soederberg in Dollars & Sense: "Educational debt has become a ticking time bomb. With over $1 trillion in outstanding loan balances, the student loan industry has a lot in common with the sub-prime mortgage industry, which went into a devastating crisis in 2007-8. Both rely on a financial innovation called “asset-backed securitization” to raise capital and to hedge risk—in other words, to raise money for loans and to reduce the likelihood that investors will lose their money."
- For Terrorist Fearmongers, It's Always the Scariest Time Ever - Glennzilla at the Intercept: "Here we are 14 years after 9/11, and it’s still always the worst threat ever in all of history, never been greater. If we always face the greatest threat ever, then one of two things is true: 1) fearmongers serially exaggerate the threat for self-interested reasons, or 2) they’re telling the truth — the threat is always getting more severe, year after year — which might mean we should evaluate the wisdom of “terrorism” policies that constantly make the problem worse."
Sunday, 21 June 2015 - 6:14pm
This week, I have been mostly reading:
- PPE for the people - Joel Lazarus and Neil Howard at openDemocracy: "Our alternative is called – wait for it – PPE, or “People’s Political Economy.” In the summer of 2012 we and two other Oxford-based academics/activists came together to set up their own response to this situation. We agreed to establish a political economy education project to enable Oxford communities to learn about and respond to the crisis. At its heart, our PPE is based on a simple but powerful democratic premise: that all people have the right and the ability to understand the world for themselves, individually and collectively."
- Resilience and ‘counter-resilience’ - Kevin Harris at the Neighbourhoods Blog: "if we use the term, there’s a risk of doing so in collusion with forces and ideologies that seek to embed ‘resilience’ within the status quo. This in turn […] effectively undermines other forms of resilience."
- Publisher pushback puts open access in peril - Virginia Barbour in the Conversation: "Elsevier’s new policy is a substantial tightening of its rules around Green OA. It states that, if no APC is paid, the author’s accepted version of the article cannot be made publicly available via their institution’s repository until after an embargo period, which ranges from six months to four years. In addition, the license required is the most restrictive possible, in that it prohibits commercial reuse, or use of excerpts of the work."
- Myth of the Garbage Patch - Maya Weeks, the New Enquiry: "According to Jeffrey Meikle, author of American Plastic: A Cultural History, after World War II resin makers “mounted a major educational effort to accommodate the consumer to new, previously unknown plastics. People neither naturally gravitated to the stuff, nor did they instinctively throw it away, so the industry also had to insulate consumers to plastic’s disposability.” It’s no coincidence that the escalation of the abovementioned effects–the rise in hungry whales, shark attacks, dying coral, anoxic zones and so on and so forth–have coincided with quadrupled plastics production since the massive neoliberal deregulation of the 1980s."
- Income Inequalities in Perspective - Jomo Kwame Sundaram and Vladimir Popov for the ILO: All the graphs you'll need for the rest of this year's arguments over Piketty.
- Trade and Trust - Paul Krugman, NYT: "Instead of addressing real concerns, however, the Obama administration has been dismissive, trying to portray skeptics as uninformed hacks who don’t understand the virtues of trade. But they’re not: the skeptics have on balance been more right than wrong about issues like dispute settlement, and the only really hackish economics I’ve seen in this debate is coming from supporters of the trade pact."
- Sharing information on student protests - Ingrid Robeyns at Crooked Timber: "Students and staff who are occupying and protesting: share information!"
- A Fascinating Minimum-Wage Experiment Is About to Unfold - John Cassidy at the New Yorker: "An important question, from a policy-analysis perspective, is how the new wage laws will affect employment levels in the cities that have introduced them. It is now almost twenty-five years since the labor economists David Card and Alan B. Krueger, who were then both at Princeton, published a famous study challenging the prevailing orthodoxy that raises in the minimum wage inevitably lead to declines in hiring, particularly among teen-agers."
- The University of the Spectacle - James Compton, The Public Intellectuals Project: "The University of the Spectacle inverts the academy’s core values. Students and researchers of social work, English literature or visual arts will not find themselves in these images. No sociology will be committed. Indeed, all traces of scholarship have been removed. The utilitarian managerialism at the heart of the University of the Spectacle has no time for such activities. After all, where is the value-added proposition?"
- Ten Ideas to Save the Economy #5. Reinvent Education: I like Robert Reich. He means well. But count the ocurrences of phrases like "a more competitive workforce" versus "better-informed and engaged citizens". It isn't the job of public education to save the economy.
- Austerity Bites: Fiscal Lessons from the British General Election - : "The economic crisis that hastened New Labour’s demise had nothing to do with overspending and everything to do with its uncritical acceptance of twenty-first-century financial innovation and its excesses. Before analysts conclude that Labour has no choice but to shift to the right, we need to remember the lessons of the global financial crisis: a balanced budget will not save a government from the failures of a banking sector that is too big to bail out, and mere economic facts seldom defeat ideologies."
- The Corporate Archipelago - Paul Krugman, NYT: "[…] I just participated in a panel on the future of capitalism. I know, why such a small topic? But what I found myself thinking and talking about is actually the present of capitalism — and in particular about the peculiar delusion that we live in a world of individual competition in freewheeling markets."
- Grexit and the Morning After - Yes, Krugman again; he's on top form: "[…] the bigger question is what happens a year or two after Grexit, where the real risk to the euro is not that Greece will fail but that it will succeed. Suppose that a greatly devalued new drachma brings a flood of British beer-drinkers to the Ionian Sea, and Greece starts to recover. This would greatly encourage challengers to austerity and internal devaluation elsewhere."
- The bad intelligence - This Modern World by Tom Tomorrow in Daily Kos: Now that we know what we know… y'know…?
- Our Mania for Hope Is a Curse - Chris Hedges plays Cassandra rather well at Truthdig: "The Dark Ages were marked by arbitrary rule, incessant wars, insecurity, anarchy and terror. And I see nothing to prevent the rise of a new Dark Age if we do not abolish the corporate state. Indeed, the longer the corporate state holds power the more likely a new Dark Age becomes. To trust in some mythical force called progress to save us is to become passive before corporate power. The people alone can defy these forces. And fate and history do not ensure our victory. "
- The Big Meh - Krugman keeps hitting them out of the park: "[…] writing and talking breathlessly about how technology changes everything might seem harmless, but, in practice, it acts as a distraction from more mundane issues — and an excuse for handling those issues badly. If you go back to the 1930s, you find many influential people saying the same kinds of things such people say nowadays […] And then, thanks to World War II, we finally got the demand boost we needed, and all those supposedly unqualified workers — not to mention Rosie the Riveter — turned out to be quite useful in the modern economy, if given a chance."
- Nash equilibrium - Tony Curzon Price at openDemocracy: "There is nothing intrinsic to game theory that says that preferences should be self-regarding or that players should not care about the pay-offs to others. That is a layer of psychology and sociology on top of Nash's mathematics and utterly separable from it. Nash's result will apply as much (or, perhaps, as little) in a den of thieves as in a paradise of saints."
- SourceForge commits reputational suicide - Simon Phipps, Infoworld: "Once the darling of open source, SourceForge has been eclipsed by GitHub and package managers, leaving it with a long, thin tail of (mostly consumer) software. It has used increasingly desperate measures to monetize the service through questionable advertising, SEO, and adware injectors."
- Reporter Who Wrote Sunday Times 'Snowden' Propaganda Admits That He's Just Writing What UK Gov't Told Him - Mike Masnick at Techdirt: "In short: one government official told them this, and they asked other government officials, who all had a personal interest in having the answer be "yes" and after enough government officials all agreed on the same talking point, good boy Tom Harper wrote it all down and presented it as fact."
Sunday, 14 June 2015 - 5:38pm
This week, I have been mostly reading, and what I have been mostly reading is:
- Killing Bin Laden: Seymour Hersh's Explosive Revelations Are Worth Taking Seriously - Michael Brull at New Matilda: … Because it's Seymour Fucking Hersh. There are just some authorities for whom the appeal to authority is not a logical fallacy. Also, does anybody at this point think that Obama would hestitate for a second before cheerfully ordering a hit on a defenseless elderly cripple under house arrest? It was probably a deeply-held ambition long before bin Laden emerged as a possible target. There'll be some innocent old guy in a nursing home in Jalalabad or somewhere who's only alive and eating custard pudding today because bin Laden pushed him out of the frame. Also:
- The media’s reaction to Seymour Hersh’s bin Laden scoop has been disgraceful - Trevor Timm in Columbia Journalism Review: "It has been rich watching journalists fall over each other to see who can more vehemently criticize Hersh’s use of anonymous sources, despite the fact that using anonymous sources is a tried-and-true Washington ritual that receives almost no criticism in day-to-day reporting. Banal sound bites are regularly printed on the front pages without names attached, and entire press conferences are held every day with “senior government officials” who refuse to be named."
- Pyne Ignores The Elephant In The Lecture Hall: Reactions To The Higher Ed Budget - Max Chalmers, New Matilda
- David Graeber and the Bureaucratic Utopia of Drone Warfare - Cora Currier (who must be heartily sick of jokes about being the hipper culinary equivalent of Dora the Explorer) at the Intercept: 'We might think of police as principally protecting us from violent crime, solving murders and muggings and rapes, but they are mainly occupied in enforcing disputes over property and non-violent behaviors. “Bureaucrats with guns,” as Graeber puts it.'
- Those who half make reformism dig only their own graves - James Meadway at openDemocracy.net: "The dense, corrupt networks of power and privilege at the centre of British political life will not allow space for anything less than a thoroughgoing commitment to neoliberal values. Miliband was duly hung out to dry. It is necessary to either accept those values, or make a clean break." Does anybody have Neil Kinnock's phone number?
- The Jeb Bush Adviser Who Should Scare You - David Corn at MoJo: "Wolfowitz and all his senior-level colleagues in the Bush-Cheney administration got Iraq wrong. They each were guilty of wishful thinking and arrogantly believed they knew better than area experts in various government agencies. But within this crew, as a ferocious advocate of a wacky and paranoid conspiracy theory, Wolfowitz went further in denying reality." Also:
- Fraternity of Failure - Paul Krugman at the NYT: "Jeb Bush wants to stop talking about past controversies. And you can see why. He has a lot to stop talking about." And:
- Errors and Lies - Krugman again: "The campaign of lies that took us into Iraq was recent enough that it’s still important to hold the guilty individuals accountable. Never mind Jeb Bush’s verbal stumbles. Think, instead, about his foreign-policy team, led by people who were directly involved in concocting a false case for war."
- "Whiteness," Criminality and the Double Standards of Deviance/Social Control - Truthout's abridged version of Nancy A. Heitzeg's article: "White criminality is increasingly defined and controlled via the medical model. This is made possible by the white racial frame, which constructs 'whiteness' as normative and white deviance as individual aberration or mental illness. Conversely, the white racial frame constructs Blackness as synonymous with criminality. […] The result is double standards of definition and control which medicalize whiteness and criminalize Blackness. This differential framing of whiteness and Blackness provides the foundation for the expansion of both the medical and prison industrial complexes, which are characterized by real racial differences despite comparable patterns of deviance across racial lines."
- Would graduating more college students reduce wage inequality? - Marshall Steinbaum at the Washington Center for Equitable Growth: "The key to reducing inequality is more jobs and a higher demand for labor. In the absence of more jobs, heroic assumptions about educational improvement are likely to deliver only modest economic benefits." See also:
- The One Where Larry Summers Demolished the Robots and Skills Arguments - Mike Konczal at the Roosevelt Institute: Quoth Summers, "What we need is more demand and that goes to short run cyclical policy, more generally to how we operate macroeconomic policy, and the enormous importance of having tighter labor markets, so that firms have an incentive to reach for worker, rather than workers having to reach for firms."
- The Laffer hypothesis in Australia - John Quiggin: Apparently, the IPA invited Arthur Laffer to Australia. In 2015. Not 1985. Oh to be present at the meeting of minds between an aged court astrologer and the whey-faced adolescents of the IPA. "One thing we've always wondered, this 'napkin': so this was some sort of early smartphone or tablet? Like a Blackberry?"
- Forget What We Know Now: We Knew Then the Iraq War Was a Joke - Matt Taibbi at Rolling Stone, plus Paul Krugman at the NYT, plus plenty of other people in the reality-based community.
- The student debt boom (cont.) - LBO News from Doug Henwood: "Since the official end of the Great Recession in June 2009, households have been borrowing very cautiously (how much it’s their decision, their lenders’ decision, or a combination of the two, isn’t fully clear). The glaring exception is student debt."
- Money, Inflation, and Models - Paul Kruman, NYT: "This is actually wonderful: economic theory used to make a prediction about events far outside usual experience, with the theory’s predictions very much at odds with the conventional wisdom of practical men — and the theory was right. True, basically nobody has changed his mind — the people who predicted runaway inflation remain utterly convinced that they know how the world works. But you can’t have everything."
- New Labour’s Economic Illiteracy Exacts a Terrible Price: “I’m afraid there is no money.” - Bill Black at NEP: "The single most insane post-crisis New Labour policy has been the fervent embrace of economically illiterate and self-destructive austerity. This means that the people New Labour appointed to senior financial leadership positions like Byrne had to be – or pretend to be – unfit for their jobs. In either case – true or feigned ignorance that is causing devastating harm to the public – the official has to be unfit – intellectually or morally (or both)."
- Life in a windowless box: the vertical slums of Melbourne - Ralph Horne and Megan Nethercote in the Conversation: "Developers in Melbourne can build at four times the densities allowed in New York, Tokyo or Hong Kong. Moreover, inner city developers are generally under no obligation to contribute to essential public infrastructure, such as affordable housing and community facilities, through density bonus systems. The findings are nothing short of damning, not least for a city that prizes itself, year on year, as the “world’s most liveable city”."
- Consuming wealth without spending a dime - Frances Wooley for a Worthwhile Canadian Initiative: "If I was poor, it would be tough having an old, unreliable car. The unexpected, yet inevitable, major repairs would be a financial nightmare. $750 to repair the clutch. $200 to fix the axel seal. If the car broke broke down, and I couldn't get to work, I might lose my job. But because I'm financially secure, I can afford a cheap car. I can self-insure against financial risks: unexpected repair costs, taxi fares, rental cars, and so on. I can afford to get my car towed. If it was beyond repair, I could get another car tomorrow." And in recent months I have been repeating to my cats "Don't get sick. Don't get sick…"
- I'm a liberal professor, and my liberal students terrify me - "Edward Schlosser", Vox: "I once saw an adjunct not get his contract renewed after students complained that he exposed them to "offensive" texts written by Edward Said and Mark Twain. His response, that the texts were meant to be a little upsetting, only fueled the students' ire and sealed his fate."
- How US students get a university degree for free in Germany - Franz Strasser, BBC News, Germany: "'It's not unattractive for us when knowledge and know-how come to us from other countries and result in jobs when these students have a business idea and stay in Berlin to create their start-up,' says Steffen Krach, Berlin's Secretary of Science."
- Platforms All the Way Down - John Herrman at the Awl: "Platform conflict, private or public, sensible or capricious, explicit or implied, will determine the manners in which we read and watch and communicate and produce online. A type of co-dependency that would be familiar in any advanced industry becomes incomprehensible at such scale and seemingly boundless acceleration—a billion users as unsure about what they’re seeing as where they’re seeing it from."
- 'Harro prease': Will SBS's 'Scott McIntyre Standard' Apply To This Journalist's Comment? - Max Chalmers at New Matilda: The capricious politics of context collapse.
- Cheney Thought al Qaeda was Bluffing - Jon Schwartz at the Intercept: "So it’s not just that Cheney is cartoonishly evil, it’s that he’s monstrously incompetent; in fact, his monstrous incompetence is a large part of why he’s so cartoonishly evil. He was overwhelmingly powerful, but with no understanding of reality, and so blundered around the world strewing destruction wherever he went."
- Restoring the Public’s Trust in Economists - Mark Thoma at the Fiscal Times: A good overview of the "mathiness" debate. "What is mathiness? Berkeley’s Brad DeLong defines it as “restricting your microfoundations in advance to guarantee a particular political result and hiding what you are doing in a blizzard of irrelevant and ungrounded algebra.”"
Sunday, 7 June 2015 - 6:47pm
This week, I have been mostly reading:
- Tie Day: R.I.P. Professor Gusfield - Doug Hartmann at the Society Pages: 'His primary accomplishment is to show how our usual focus on drinking-driving as the moral failing of individual citizens distracts from the institutional and structural problems of traffic and transportation, leisure-time use, urban design, ambiguities in the law, the power of corporate marketing, and the inherent dangers of driving itself are so very much a part of the “problem” as well.'
- What’s the Point of a Professor? - : "You can’t become a moral authority if you rarely challenge students in class and engage them beyond it. If we professors do not do that, the course is not an induction of eager minds into an enlarging vision. It is a requirement to fulfill. Only our assistance with assignments matters"
- Australia's Own Version Of Islamic State Destruction Of Sacred Objects And People - William Scates Frances at New Matilda: "According to the New South Wales office of the Environment and Heritage, in a single year between June of 2012 and June 2013, over 99 applications for destruction of sites of Aboriginal heritage were considered. All were approved."
- The University after Conservative Victory - Chris Newfield at Remaking the University: "Trivializing society has of course been a highly successful core project of the political Right. That doesn't change the possibility of showing that most of the total value of education is collective, based on network effects (I'm smarter because my neighbor is smarter and also because an unknown Scottish villager became smarter 30 years ago, with endless ripples outward and everywhere). All these spillovers, externalities and indirect effects through multiple variables, though they seem beyond the grasp of current political rationality, are the deep sources of real progress." Or, as Brendan Behan would say, "I never went to school, but I met the scholars coming back."
- For-Profit Colleges Face a Loan Revolt by Thousands Claiming Trickery - Tamar Lewin, NYT: "'So the department first makes the loans that lets students go to these fraudulent and then when the students can’t pay back the loans, the department goes after them.'"
- Life in the Accelerated Academy: anxiety thrives, demands intensify and metrics hold the tangled web together - Mark Carrigan at the LSE: "As David Cameron put it recently, “if you’re not good or outstanding, you have to change … if you can’t do it yourself, you have to let experts come in and help you”. He was talking about secondary education rather than higher education but I’ve yet to encounter a more succinct statement of what the political theorist Will Davies memorably describes as heating up the floor to see who can keep hopping the longest."
- What Tony Abbott talks about when he talks about ‘welfare’ - Gabrielle Meagher and David P. Wilkins in the Australian Review of Public Affairs: "The most significant way that Mr Abbott’s talk expresses his politics is through the direction of the relationship between ‘having a go’ and ‘a fair go’. As we showed above, a fair go is dependent on having a go in Mr Abbott’s framing. The Prime Minister presents this as a causal argument: generous social support (‘welfare’) can come only after the economy produces the necessary resources. The point has a certain (trivial) force—it is desirable to fund social security from a surplus in total economic output in any particular period. However, the causal relationship between the extent of economic success and the level social support has been much debated. And there is at least some good evidence that the direction of causation goes the other way—from generous social supports to economic prosperity . In day-to-day party politics, debate about the direction of causation is played out in an ideological conflict, in which Mr Abbott comes down on the side of economic growth before social support."
- The New York Times’ Secret Rule Forbidding Its EU Writers from Reading Krugman - Bill Black at NEP carries out an autopsy on New Labour and finds death by mediamacro: 'New Labour has had “no clear guiding philosophy” from the beginning because its strategy of becoming Red Tories and joining the Conservative Party’s assaults on the working class and regulation and its championing of the most corrupt elite bank officers in the world is not a “philosophy.” At best, it is a craven political tactic that depends for its (temporary) electoral success on spectacularly unpopular Tory leadership.'
- Cameron rebooted: five more years of a shiny computerised toe in a prime-ministerial suit - Charlie Brooker playing Charlie Brooker at the Guardian: "The glaring disparity between the weeks of pre-election polling and the actual result is surely useful scientific data: perhaps the most comprehensive investigation into the difference between what people claim to think and what they actually think ever undertaken. Clearly, voting Tory is a guilty pleasure some people won’t readily admit to – like masturbating or listening to Gary Barlow. Or masturbating while listening to Gary Barlow. In the voting booth. Using your free hand to vote Conservative. Cameron’s Britain."
- The last gasp of (US) neoliberalism - John Quiggin
- The Secret Corporate Takeover - Joe Stiglitz provides Project Syndicate with the if-you-only-read-one-article-on-the-TPP article
Sunday, 31 May 2015 - 12:22pm
This week, I have been mostly frantically writing essays, with a bit of reading:
- Basic Income and the Anti-Slavery Movement - Neil Howard at openDemocracy cross-posted to Truthout: "No advocate of basic income wants it set high enough to discourage work. Rather, the goal is to give people the "real freedom" to sayNo! to bad jobs and Yes! to good ones. Remember that in the West, it is the punitive social security system which itself creates unemployment traps. If instead of tax-breaks or top-ups we gave people UBI, then nobody would ever face the choice of losing money by accepting work."
- The media’s reaction to Seymour Hersh’s bin Laden scoop has been disgraceful - Trevor Timm in Columbia Journalism Review: "All this brings to mind a story from earlier in Hersh’s career, when, as a relatively unknown reporter in Vietnam, he put together the pieces of his My Lai scoop."
- Corinthian Colleges Secretly Funded D.C. Think Tanks, Dark Money Election Efforts - Lee Fang, the Intercept: …and then declared bankruptcy. But sure, Australia should model its higher education system on the US one!
- Student Organisations Must Be 'Compliant' And 'Cooperative' Says University, As It Tries To Shut One Down - Max Chalmers at New Matilda: A "Student Advisory Board" isn't a union. "No individual or organisation that is beholden to or answers to the University can advocate fully and openly without fear of reprisal."
- Struggle Street is poverty porn with an extra dose of class racism - Steven Threadgold in the Conversation
- The Wars Come Home A Five-Step Guide to the Police Repression of Protest from Ferguson to Baltimore and Beyond - Michael Gould-Wartofsky at TomDispatch: "The point of all of this: to keep an eye on our posts and tweets, intimidate protesters before they hit the streets, pen them in on those streets, and ensure that they pay a heavy price for exercising their right to assemble and speak. The message is loud and clear in twenty-first-century America: protest at your peril."
- Economists: Drop the Signaling Fad - Noah Smith at Bloomberg View: "Employers want employees who are smart, conscientious, hard-working and team-oriented. But they can’t tell most of those things from an interview or two. So prospective employees might prove themselves by getting some credential -- completing some difficult educational program -- to prove they have what it takes. Thus was born the signaling theory of education."
- Stop-Go Austerity and Self-Defeating Recoveries - Paul Krugman, NYT: "Cameron and company imposed austerity for a couple of years, then paused, and the economy picked up enough during the lull to give them a chance to make the same mistakes all over again."
- Transportation Emerges as Crucial to Escaping Poverty - Mikayla Bouchard, NYT: "The relationship between transportation and social mobility is stronger than that between mobility and several other factors, like crime, elementary-school test scores or the percentage of two-parent families in a community, said Nathaniel Hendren, a Harvard economist and one of the researchers on the study."
- The future of work in the second machine age is up to us - : "Summers’ co-panelist David Autor added that since 2000, the education wage premium has reached a plateau and the rate of over-education has increased, both of which are hard to square with the argument that the reason for rising inequality is the advance of technology. Summers added that the idea that more education solves the problem of displaced labor is “fundamentally an evasion.”" , Washington Center for Equitable Growth
Sunday, 24 May 2015 - 6:56pm
This week, I have been riddled with angst, hopelessness, and despair, and have been mostly reading:
- The early bird gets the worm - Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal by Zach Weiner
- Anzacs behaving badly: Scott McIntyre and contested history - Philip Dwyer at The Conversation: "There is an obvious disconnect between what historians know and what the popular perception of our past is. It is this disconnect that has jarred with some in the public and led to McIntyre’s sacking. […] It is difficult if not impossible for historians to overturn popular myths. Myths are popular because they represent stories we want to hear; they feed into the collective psyche. Anzacs behaving badly is not something we want to acknowledge."
- Give 'Em Hell, Bernie - Matt Taibbi at Rolling Stone: "Sanders genuinely, sincerely, does not care about optics. He is the rarest of Washington animals, a completely honest person. If he's motivated by anything other than a desire to use his influence to protect people who can't protect themselves, I've never seen it."
- Hillary Clinton Condemns Criminal Justice System Her Husband Helped Build - Andrew Jerrell Jones at The Intercept: "During Bill Clinton’s eight years in the White House, the number of people imprisoned by the federal government nearly doubled, from 85,565 in 1993 to 156,572 in 2001."
- “I could be a father, but I could never be a mother”: Research on Childfree Women in Canada - Interview with Gillian Ayers: "For many of the women, if they couldn’t mother the “right” way, they weren’t going to do it at all. This belief became apparent to me when, for example, 20 of the 21 women I spoke with cited financial reasons for remaining voluntarily childless." That's the showstopper for our stereotypically cat-centric household. Precarity is incompatible with parenthood.
- Cowardly Firing of Australian State-Funded TV Journalist Highlights the West’s Real Religion - Glenn Greenwald at the Intercept: '“SBS supports our Anzacs” — and apparently bars any questioning or criticism of them. That mentality sounds like it came right from North Korea, which is to be expected when a media outlet is prohibited from saying anything that offends high government officials. Any society in which it’s a firing offense for journalists to criticize the military is a sickly and undemocratic one.'
- Signaling theory and credentialing theory in sociology - Fabio Rojas at orgtheory.net: "The theory asserts that the main reason that education correlates with income is that is a signal of intelligence and work ethic, not learned skills. I.e., employers like college graduates because they are good workers, not because they have useful skills."
- The problem with wanting 'peace' in Baltimore - Kazu Haga at openDemocracy: "[C]alls for people to be “peaceful” in the face of the most recent police killing infuriate me. The calls for “peace” that act as a euphemism for “stop protesting” sickens me. When law enforcement and politicians tell people to protest “peacefully” as a way of saying “stop being so mad,” it repulses me. The gross and dangerous misunderstanding that people have of the concept of “peace” disgusts me." (see also)
- The Treasury View of HE: Variable Human Capital Investment - Andrew McGettigan, who is so much smarter than me that reading him gives me vertigo, writing for Goldsmiths, which you're not allowed to call Goldsmiths' College any more, for very serious branding-related reasons: "I have no glib solution to which you might sign up. But when hard times find us, criticism must strike for the root: the root is undergraduate study as a stratified, unequal, positional good dominating future opportunities and outcomes. What might find broader public support is a vision of higher education institutions that are civic and open to lifelong participation, instead of places beholden to the three-year, full-time degree leveraged on loans and aiming to cream off ‘talent’."
- Survey Finds Only One House In Capital Cities Affordable For Single Person On Newstart - Max Chalmers, New Matilda: "A new survey by a top charity has revealed that during one weekend last month, just 10 homes in the entire country were available for lease at rates that wouldn’t create ‘rental stress’ for a single person living on the Newstart allowance while they look for work. Only one of those homes was in a capital city – the rest were in regional areas."
- How to Talk to Your Kids About Bernie Sanders - Kimberly Harrington nails it at Medium: "We’re used to being lied to. We like it. It’s soothing. So this situation is uncomfortable for us too. Just know this: you are not alone. We will get through Truthmageddon-Honestypocalypse-2016 together."
Sunday, 17 May 2015 - 5:55pm
This week, instead of writing my final essays for the session, I have been mostly reading:
- VCs Go Missing In Action As University Whistleblowers Speak Out On Four Corners - Max Chalmers at New Matilda: "The highly anticipated program was partially based on a recent Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) investigation which warned the pressure on academics to pass students in universities was so extreme it could be conducive to corruption." Shocked! Shocked, I tell you!
- Waiting for the fallout: Australia and return of the patrimonial society - John Quiggin on the relevance of Piketty to Australia in the Australian Review of Public Affairs: "The claim that the rich are mostly self-made is already dubious, and will soon be clearly false. Of the top ten people on the Business Review Weekly (BRW) rich list for 2014, four inherited their wealth, including the top three. Two more are in their 80s, part of the talented generation of Jewish refugees who came to Australia and prospered in the years after World War II. When these two pass on, the rich list will be dominated by heirs, not founders."
- A New Deal for Greece – a Project Syndicate Op-Ed by Yanis Varoufakis: "The result of [the troika's] method, in our government’s opinion, is an “austerity trap.” When fiscal consolidation turns on a predetermined debt ratio to be achieved at a predetermined point in the future, the primary surpluses needed to hit those targets are such that the effect on the private sector undermines the assumed growth rates and thus derails the planned fiscal path. Indeed, this is precisely why previous fiscal-consolidation plans for Greece missed their targets so spectacularly."
- Statement on resignation from CPD and alternative - Public Statement by Mark Bahnisch, Eva Cox and John Quiggin: "Current policy making is shaped largely by limited influences and insider advice that fails to read public opinion or evidence. Business-funded lobbyists and think tanks dominate public debate, crowding out the very limited alternatives to current ‘verities’. Many public-minded advocates, active in the past, are silenced by the financial constraints of universities, and too many NGOs are now more dependent on government funding. There is much public disquiet about the state of our society and polity. However, few offer carefully devised and well promoted alternative options."
- Zombies of 2016 - Paul Krugman OpEdding at the NYT: "Pundits will try to pretend that we’re having a serious policy debate, but, as far as issues go, 2016 is already set up to be the election of the living dead."
- The BBC Trust: a work in progress - Jacquie Hughes at openDemocracy: I know nothing about the current structure of the BBC, which leaves me eminently qualified to speculate that BBC Worldwide appears to be the money-spinning tail that has for many years wagged the emaciated public service dog. Any avenue for genuine public accountability (as opposed to philistine euphemistic demands for financial sustainability - i.e. bleeding the patient) seems something to be welcomed.
- Miliband Goes the Full Henry Jackson - Craig Murray: "But Miliband was not admitting that the Guernica style massacre was wrong – he voted for it. No, he was going the full Henry Jackson and arguing that what had been needed was neo-colonial occupation of Libya in order to reform its institutions – precisely as had been done in Iraq. And we all know how that went."
- Rorschach Tests at the Nuremberg Trials - Neurosceptic
- After the recent tragedy in the Med, why can’t we talk about free migration? - Morten Thaysen, openDemocracy: Capital and products are assets to be welcomed, people are a liability to be demonised, spurned, and left to die. Discuss.
- Hello World Intellectual Freedom Organization - Mike Linksvayer: Mike is in the top tier of the world's smart people, and an all-round good egg. This [c|sh]ould be huge.
- The Cops Have Met Their Enemies: They Are Us - Ted Rall at aNewDomain: Bull Connor has won; it just took a while.
- The Killing of Osama bin Laden - Sy Hersh at the London Review of Books:
Some of the Seals were appalled later at the White House’s initial insistence that they had shot bin Laden in self-defence, the retired official said. ‘Six of the Seals’ finest, most experienced NCOs, faced with an unarmed elderly civilian, had to kill him in self-defence? […] The rules gave them absolute authority to kill the guy.’ The later White House claim that only one or two bullets were fired into his head was ‘bullshit’, the retired official said. ‘The squad came through the door and obliterated him. As the Seals say, “We kicked his ass and took his gas.”’
- Did I ever mention that I fucking hate the fucking web - Chris Bloom and a language warning: My obvious tl;dr is "Don't use a web service for anything you can do on your own computer."
- Greatest Threat to Free Speech Comes Not From Terrorism, But From Those Claiming to Fight It - Glenn Greenwald at the Intercept: 'Basking in his election victory, Prime Minister David Cameron unleashed this Orwellian decree to explain why new Thought Police powers are needed: “For too long, we have been a passively tolerant society, saying to our citizens ‘as long as you obey the law, we will leave you alone.'” It’s not enough for British subjects merely to “obey the law”; they must refrain from believing in or expressing ideas which Her Majesty’s Government dislikes.'
- 10 Writing Tips from Legendary Writing Teacher William Zinsser, May He Rest in Peace - Ted Milles on Open Culture: "Very few sentences come out right the first time, or even the third time. Remember this in moments of despair. If you find that writing is hard, it’s because it is hard."
- Democratically controlled, co-operative higher education - Joss Winn at openDemocracy: "In short, co-operative higher education is entirely compatible with the idea of the ‘public’ if we reconceive it as an autonomous, open, democratically governed ‘commons’: An academic commons, democratically controlled by academic and support staff, students, cleaners and others."
Sunday, 10 May 2015 - 6:18pm
Things have been more grim than ever (and that's saying something) in our little Colorbond-clad corner of sunny Sawtell. Fortunately, I can always escape reality via the Internet. This week, I have been mostly reading:
- Lesser-Known Trolley Problem Variations - Kyle York at McSweeney's Internet Tendency: "The Time Traveller: There’s an out of control trolley speeding towards a worker. You have the ability to pull a lever and change the trolley’s path so it hits a different worker. The different worker is actually the first worker ten minutes from now."
- Do you ever really own a computerized device? - Toronto Globe and Mail interviews Cory Doctorow: "So this creates this really weird regime where effectively you get to make up your own laws: You put a lock on, you prevent something from happening and suddenly it becomes illegal to do that. Even if Parliament or Congress never sat down to do that. Can that law really pass constitutional muster?"
- The History of the Future of the Push-Button School - Audrey Watters: "'The high school becomes partially transformed into a center run by administrators and clerks, with a minimum of the routine assigned to the teaching staff. […] The creation of educational material moves partially out into industry, which goes into the education business in partnership with educators.'"
- ‘They,’ the Singular Pronoun, Gets Popular - Ben Zimmer, WSJ: People like me have strong feelings about issues like this.
- Government inquiry takes aim at green charities that ‘get political’ - Peter Burdon on the Conversation: "While conceding that the Hawke review may be interpreted as an “attack on [environmental organisations'] efforts to protect the environment”, [Gary] Johns also argued that governments “should be reticent” about supporting organisations that “promote viewpoints on issues where there is reasonable disagreement in the electorate”. It is difficult to see what organisations would satisfy such a test. Certainly not the Institute of Public Affairs, the Chifley Research Centre or Menzies House, which also enjoy tax deductibility but seem unlikely to face the same scrutiny advocated by Hawke."
- The triple crisis of sociology - Ivan Szelenyi at Contexts: "Sociology is indeed in a triple crisis. It responds the wrong way to “scientific” challenge coming from neo-classical economics and rational choice political science. It either imitates them or moves into trendy interdisciplinary fields just to regain its lost constituency." Also check out Ivan's Foundations of Modern Social Theory lectures. I didn't know he taught at Flinders University in the 70s. My, that Hungarian accent seems hard to shake off.
- Shorter - Cory Doctorow at Locus Online: "My experience contrasts with the moral panic over the decline in writing standards due to the Internet. Those who wring their hands at the informality and vernacular of instant messaging and social media prose have missed the point: when we practice writing short, for an audience, as a kind of performance, it makes us better writers"
Sunday, 3 May 2015 - 6:49pm
This week, I have been mostly reading:
- Matter Over Mind - Paul Krugman, NYT: "[…] belief that income inequality is all about, and can be fixed by, education is even more wrong than you thought."
- Stop subsidising for-profit education - John Quiggin
- Ed-Tech's Inequalities - Audrey Watters: "Education technology will close the achievement gap; education technology will close the opportunity gap. Education technology will revolutionize; education technology will democratize. Or so we are told."
- 6 Things Warwick University’s New Temp Agency Tells Us About Academic Precarity - John Murray on Novara Wire
- Ezra Klein of Vox.com vs. Tom Standage of The Economist - Brad DeLong, Washington Center for Equitable Growth: Aggregation with attribution vs. authority silo.
- The shadowy world of IPA finances - Clive Hamilton on the Drum: "The IPA is notoriously secretive about its sources of funding. Its senior staff have refused to answer journalists' questions, although over the years enough information has leaked out to suggest that much of its funding has come from the oil and mining industries, including Exxon, Shell, Caltex and BHP-Billiton."
- Malice in Wonderland - Desmond Manderson, Arena: "Abbott’s ‘felicific calculus’ is that more people are made happier by ‘stopping the boats’, even if some people—those stuck on Manus or Nauru, for example—are made very unhappy indeed. Let me repeat: our government is prepared to turn a blind eye to, or to condone, perhaps even intentionally devise, actions that amount to torture, so long as it helps it realize its goals. Has there ever been a case like it in Australian history? The violation of human rights is not an accident; it’s a policy. Net happiness has increased, so we have nothing to apologise for."
- The hottest tax idea in Washington is actually terrible - Marshall I. Steinbaum, the Week: Consumption tax. This time, it won't just be an outrageous gift to the rich. Honest.
- Servitude: the way we work now - People who in law are free are bound by economic necessity to work for less than the living wage (‘apprenticeships’), no pay (‘internships’), or in uncertain conditions (‘zero-hours’ contracts). They are free to leave if they wish. Like Okies in the Dust Bowl they can load up the truck. They at least had Steinbeck and Woody Guthrie. Who speaks for the zero people?"
Sunday, 26 April 2015 - 6:38pm
This week, I have been mostly sick as a dog. I might have read the following, though it could all have been a delusion brought on by fever and lack of sleep:
- Using Wikipedia: a scholar redraws academic lines by including it in his syllabus - Ellis Jones at the Conversation: Hooray! And well, d'uh. But mostly hooray!
- First we take Amsterdam, then we take The Hague - On April 1, representatives of staff and students from the occupied Maagdenhuis at the University of Amsterdam (UvA) came to an agreement with the University’s Executive Board (CvB) concerning the formation of two independent committees, one to investigate UvA’s finances and another to investigate possibilities for decentralization and democratization."
- Students, Solidarity Strikes and Shutting Down Austerity at the Point of Production: The Social Vision of the 2015 Quebec Student Strike - Jonathan Leavit, Toward Freedom: "Bela recounts how inside his organizing conversations, technical education students were skeptical about organizing around education, because their programs are already commodified, privileging market demands over educational outcomes. 'If you tell them, well, you won’t have any kindergarten. You will have to stay at home or your partner will have to stay at home. What kind of society do you want? Then they’re ready to strike.'"
- Time Is Money Is Work Is Virtue - Colette Shade at the Baffler: "The iPhone has allowed office workers to be available anywhere, at any time. The Apple Watch is both a logical next step and a throwback to time measurement’s industrial origins."
- Warwick Uni to outsource hourly paid academics to subsidiary - Fighting Against Casualisation in Education
- The Automatic Teacher - Audrey Watters at boundary 2: "This does not mean, in any unfortunate sense, the mechanization of education. It does mean freeing the teacher from the drudgeries of her work so that she may do more real teaching, giving the pupil more adequate guidance in his learning. There may well be an ‘industrial revolution’ in education. The ultimate results should be highly beneficial. Perhaps only by such means can universal education be made effective."
- The Australian Sharia Lobby - John Quiggin: "The prospect of any significant legislation being based on Islamic sharia law seems pretty remote. On the other hand, those who claim to be concerned about sharia law (the Arabic term simply means ‘religious law) might want to consider the much more relevant issue of ‘sharīʿat al-Masīḥ’ (the Arabic term for ‘religious law of Christianity’)."
- The Big Chill: How Big Money Is Buying Off Criticism of Big Money - Robert Reich: "It’s bad enough big money is buying off politicians. It’s also buying off nonprofits that used to be sources of investigation, information, and social change, from criticizing big money. Other sources of funding are drying up. Research grants are waning. Funds for social services of churches and community groups are growing scarce. Legislatures are cutting back university funding. Appropriations for public television, the arts, museums, and libraries are being slashed."
- Dear Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook is not, and should not be the internet - SavetheInternet.in coalition, Hindustan Times
- Yanis Varoufakis in conversation with Joseph Stiglitz on the Eurozone Crisis – at the INET-OECD conference, 9 April 2015 (video)